Wherever there are banks, there are bank failures and banking crises.
Was there a fourth century banking crisis? Why did banks fail in Classical Athens? How did they fail? Did Classical Athens have a resolution authority or deposit guarantee scheme?
0:00 – Intro
0:33 Demosthenes 33 – Pasion’s bank’s survival amidst failures
2:50 a 4th century systemic banking crisis?
5:48 Demosthenes 36 – bank insolvency in action
14:45 Deposit guarantee schemes?
18:05 Wrap up – small enough to fail?
Primary Sources:
– Demosthenes 33, 36.
Secondary Souces
MacDowell, Demosthenes Speeches 27-38
Cohen, Athenian Economy and Society: a Banking Perspective
Boegart, – Die Krise der Banken in Athen im 4. Jahrhundert v.u. Z. (in Hellenische Poleis, ed Welskopf)
Note: captions not yet edited
#toobigtofail #banking #bankcrisis #bankfailure #ancientgreece #ancientgreek #classics
#ancientgreece #toobigtofail #classics #banking #bankfailure #bankcrisis…(read more)
LEARN MORE ABOUT: Bank Failures
REVEALED: Best Investment During Inflation
HOW TO INVEST IN GOLD: Gold IRA Investing
HOW TO INVEST IN SILVER: Silver IRA Investing
Bank Failures in Classical Athens
Classical Athens, known for its democratic system and intellectual prowess, experienced a number of bank failures during its heyday. These failures had significant consequences for the Athenian economy and society, shedding light on the challenges faced by ancient financial institutions and their impact on the overall stability of the city-state.
In ancient Athens, banks played a crucial role in facilitating trade and commerce. They provided loans, accepted deposits, and maintained accounts for individuals and businesses. As Athens flourished and its economy expanded, the demand for banking services grew exponentially. However, this rapid growth exposed inherent vulnerabilities within the banking sector.
One of the primary causes of bank failures in Athens was irresponsible lending. Some banks were guilty of issuing loans without sufficient collateral or conducting proper due diligence. This led to a high number of defaulters, resulting in significant losses for the banks. Additionally, corrupt practices such as embezzlement and fraud further weakened the financial institutions, eroding public trust in the banking system.
Another factor contributing to bank failures was a lack of regulatory oversight. In classical Athens, there was little to no government regulation of the banking sector. While this allowed for economic freedom and innovation, it also created an environment where banks operated with unchecked risk-taking behavior. Without regulatory measures to ensure sound lending practices and monitor the financial health of the banks, the system became susceptible to manipulation and collapse.
Furthermore, external factors such as economic downturns and military campaigns impacted the financial stability of Athens. During times of war, banks faced immense challenges due to reduced trade, disrupted supply chains, and the likelihood of default by borrowers employed in affected industries or conscripted into military service. These external shocks often pushed weak banks over the edge, exacerbating an already fragile financial situation.
The consequences of bank failures were far-reaching and multifaceted. Firstly, depositors who had entrusted their savings to these banks faced significant losses, sometimes resulting in financial ruin for individuals and businesses. This eroded confidence in the banking system and led to a decrease in deposits and lending activity, hampering economic growth.
The state itself was affected by the failures, as it heavily relied on loans from these banks to fund public initiatives and finance military expeditions. Bankruptcies threatened the government’s ability to maintain stability and continue funding public projects, ultimately undermining the city-state’s prosperity and power.
To counter these challenges, Athens took some measures to restore confidence in its banking system. It introduced legislation that aimed to regulate and supervise banking activities more effectively. The laws aimed to address irresponsible lending practices, fraud, embezzlement, and enhance the overall transparency of financial transactions. The government also provided limited bailouts to some failing banks to prevent a complete collapse of the system, albeit with mixed success.
The bank failures in classical Athens provide valuable insights into the importance of prudential regulations, accountability, and risk management in maintaining a stable financial system. Without effective oversight and adherence to sound banking practices, even the most advanced societies can succumb to failures that have far-reaching and lasting consequences.
As society and economies evolve, the lessons learned from these historical experiences should not be forgotten. Financial institutions must continually strive for transparency, responsible lending practices, and effective regulatory frameworks to safeguard the stability of our banking systems, enabling economic progress and minimizing the impact of potential future failures.
a fascinating discussion. I just wish these subjects got discussed more in mainstream histories.
Commoner here (so please forgive my ignorance I know nothing of finance or business law): never understood why in modern banking the personal assets of the employees who make significant profits by being in the business, are not partially taken over. If a CEO gets paid £15 million by running a bank and his/her bank fails, those £15 million came from moneys they made via the bank. Indeed even when banks fail the CEOs get bonuses. Which I find bizarre. Why not take that money and pay back the debt? Or does it happen and the Jo Blogs like me are kept clueless? After all that money comes from some financial exchange which was done by the bank. I know this is a super inane simplification and tinted by a skewed perception of financial multinationals, but for commoners it seems odd. There are clearly laws that prevent this from happening but I don’t get why.
And so it begs the question: in ancient times, if one could not pay a business debt would they be stripped of personal assets/finances?
Love your videos thanks for all your hard work.