Overcontributed to your Roth IRA? What steps to take?

by | May 24, 2023 | Vanguard IRA | 29 comments




What happens if you put to much in your Roth IRA or you become ineligible to contribute to your Roth IRA because your income was too high? This is not something you want to mess around with so it’s really important that you keep track or have someone like jazzWealth help you. The IRS is very clear about the rules rgarding excess contributions to your Roth IRA and the max income you can have to contribute. Today Dustin will cover these topics with you….(read more)


LEARN MORE ABOUT: IRA Accounts

INVESTING IN A GOLD IRA: Gold IRA Account

INVESTING IN A SILVER IRA: Silver IRA Account

REVEALED: Best Gold Backed IRA


If you contribute more money than the allotted limit to your Roth IRA, you have made what is known as an excess contribution. It’s important to be aware of this mistake and take steps to address it to avoid potential tax penalties.

First, let’s define what an excess contribution is in a Roth IRA. For the year 2021, the contribution limit for a Roth IRA is $6,000 if you are under age 50, and $7,000 if you are age 50 and over. If you contribute more than these limits, you have made an excess contribution.

The IRS imposes a 6% tax on the excess contribution. So, if you contributed $7,000 instead of $6,000, the excess contribution is $1,000, and you must pay a $60 tax penalty.

To fix such an issue, the first step is to identify the excess contribution and calculate the tax penalty. Once you have done that, you can choose one of two options to rectify the situation: remove the excess contribution or carry it forward to the following year.

See also  HOW TO DEPOSIT MONEY IN YOUR VANGUARD IRA! #vanguard #ira #investing #dividends #stocks #etfs #index

If you choose to remove the excess contribution, you must withdraw the excess amount, along with any earnings on the excess contribution. You must also do this before the tax-filing deadline, which is typically April 15th of the following year. This removes the contribution from your Roth IRA, and you won’t receive any tax penalty.

Another option is to carry forward the excess contribution to the following year. You may be able to avoid the penalty tax this way, but you will have to explain to the IRS what happened and why you chose this option. If you do decide to carry forward the excess contribution, you must still ensure that you do not exceed the contribution limit the following year. Otherwise, you will face the same issue.

In conclusion, making an excess contribution to your Roth IRA can be an easy mistake to make. It is crucial to identify and address it as soon as possible to avoid any unnecessary tax penalties. Careful planning and staying aware of the annual contribution limits can ensure a smooth process, without any hiccups along the way.

Gold IRA Advantages for Baby Boomers Nearing Retirement
You May Also Like
[Global Debut] “The Financial Dark King of the Dragon Emerging from the Abyss” – Delivery Guy Delivering Abortion Pills Turns Out to Be Ordered by Girlfriend? I Sacrificed Everything for You, Only to Face Such Betrayal, Truly Outrageous! #HotShortDrama #ShortDramaRecommendation #Rebirth #Urban #PowerfulWriting #City

[Global Debut] “The Financial Dark King of the Dragon Emerging from the Abyss” – Delivery Guy Delivering Abortion Pills Turns Out to Be Ordered by Girlfriend? I Sacrificed Everything for You, Only to Face Such Betrayal, Truly Outrageous! #HotShortDrama #ShortDramaRecommendation #Rebirth #Urban #PowerfulWriting #City

成为此频道的铂金以上会员即可获享优先观看最新短剧福利: 精彩短剧皆在指间,希望这些作品带给你不同的体验~ 大家好,我们是官方指间看剧, 精彩原创短剧,更新不断,带你追最新热门短剧...

29 Comments

  1. Zedo

    Many thanks for the great video Dustin ____This is an excellent video and I believe it would have been even better if you had added a couple of minutes explanation of tax implication! If you end up with a lesser amount _ you withdraw that lower amount. Is the NIA the lesser amount that you withdraw or the amount by which it is less than the original contribution? For example, you contributed 6000, there was a loss and the withdrawal amount becomes $5000 after the calculation. What is called Net income attributable (NiA)? is it the $5000 that you withdraw? Or, is it the $1000 by which it was less than the original $6000. What are the tax implications? Will claim the $1000 as a loss in you tax fling? Many thanks in advance for your help.

  2. MyNicePC

    What happens if you made a contribution while income was much higher than the limit, and had unrealized losses for the entire year?

  3. Decipher Code

    I don't like it, there's always a catch to saving for retirement. I feel like you lose either way, Roth or Traditional. I hate the IRS.

  4. M A#np

    it is still unclear how to figure out how much of gain/loss is attributable. And it is my impression that gains would be income from dividends? Is this correct? I mean if you own stock that you bought from within the IRA.. and you have not sold them.. ther is not yet anty income from those stocks.. and only dividends paid to those share would be income. Is this correct?

  5. John Keenoy

    Hey, Just found you, really found this information helpful. Hoping this question finds you. If Im not sure whether i will make under/over the income threshold for a roth ira and have already contributed for the year of 2020. What are my options if I do go over the income limit. If this finds you I'd appreciate the help!

  6. Ace Paul

    How would you handle excess contribution if it was made 2 or 3 years ago?

  7. M A#np

    it seems that another option would be to recharactor the amount over the limit, including the net attributable income for the excess? Also is seems that the excess contribution would be the last partion conttibuted and for example. say a person put in payments throughout the year once per month.. it might be only the last month or two of contributions that would have been the excess portion, and they may not have even yet been invested, and if they were, the gains would probably be a small percentage of the over all gains for the fund that year. They wouldn't have had much oppotunity to compound like other investments earlier in the year which migh have had some dividends which were reinvested.

    I can also see scenarios where a person may have had a windfall of additional income later in the tax year they they could not have planned on.. It could have been from additional work or some unearned income from investments. or a bonus. BTW, I am presuming unearned income from investments would be added to the graoss income for the eary in terms of qualifiying for contributing to a Roth IRA?

  8. Pedro Feliciano

    you just clarified a doubt I had related with Roth IRA, thank you.

  9. Niko

    I recharacterize a 300 roth contribution to a traditional, but when i received my 1099 tax form, it says taxable on box 2a. Is it incorrect?

    I know i shouldnt be taxed on the recharacterization and i should be able to deduct the traditional contribution. Can you please clarify?

  10. gmail13los

    Lets say your contributing the max amount of 6000 per year and contribute an even amount weekly to reach 6000. You choose to reinvest the dividends also. Could you change the amount per week that you contribute so the reinvested dividends wont put you over the 6000 amount for the year?

  11. danny093

    The explanation was helpful but how does one decide to either eat the 6% penalty or withdraw from their Roth and take the 10% hit on what they withdraw? I know it will roll over if I leave it there but for the sake of the return which decision will yield a higher tax return?

    ex.

    If you contribute 2k over your 5.5k and then take the 6% tax on it that is -$120. If you withdraw it that is a 10% tax of -$200. Which route is better?

    Hope the question makes sense.

  12. yasely01

    Hi love your channel. If i am a stay at home mom and can my husband open & contribute to a traditional IRA and a ROth IRA both on my name even though he already have 2 on his name? He is making alittle over $100k
    Thank you

  13. Whats_Next

    I had this happen this year 2018 for 2017 due to a large severence then retirement. 1099-R has a PJ code even though I was 64 when this happened
    Do I have to ammend 2017 return and what form do I report it on a Form 590A or 590B

  14. Karen Ricotta

    How can u convert a roth to a traditional? If you paid income tax pre roth contribution then convert will you then pay income tax again when you withdraw from your traditional?

  15. Fiorrella Worker

    Jazz, I have two roth ira can I leave one next year grow alone without contri. and the other one working or I have to cancel it one and stay with one only thank you

  16. Ben Calm

    i don't get it , why am i able to put in my roth IRA around $ 320 every two weeks form paycheck.
    and they said it's completely tax free whatever in my account when i am after 59 and 1/2

  17. Sarah Lim

    This is exactly what I needed. Thank you so much!

  18. ThetaDecay

    wish I saw this video a month ago when I made this mistake

  19. oscar torres

    Filed Single in 2017, my AGI was over $122K. Based on calculations on Fidelity, I can only do a partial contribution of 3,300 for 2018. My AGI for 2018 will be over $130K. That means i can only contribute even less for 2019. Correct?

  20. littledaddy391

    Thank You so much on this one—-I was a bit worried didnt know if that was a really bad thing..i put $300 too much in my Roth as soon as i realized it i tried to cancel the transaction but was too late.. i pull it out AS soon as it hit my account .. i will sleep a bit easier because of this video … Thanks Again

  21. ctc hawaii

    I’m single, with a Roth IRA and a traditional IRA with the same brokerage company. Is the Max contribution for both accounts 5,500 or 5,500 each?

  22. haveagreatone

    There's a cap on how much one can put into a roth ira so why does how much one makes, make a difference when they're creating the rules of the account.

  23. Mario Bros

    Hello Dustin, my understanding is that on a rothIRA you will not receive a 1099B at tax time like you would for a regular individual investment account, could you corroborate this? Thank you

  24. lowstringc

    Mic suggestion/possibility: use a wireless mic/receiver, and have a hung area mic just above the camera frame as a backup just in case. For what you do a lapel (or an ear-worn but that would look a little odd for video imo) is really best and the most consistent, and since you are doing more live and already have at least a 2 channel audio interface for those two mics, it would be good to have an overhead mic in case of any problems with the lapel. Set your gain staging well, and feel much more unencumbered and sound better to boot! Note: I wouldn’t actually use the two mics in conjunction or you might get some weird phase cancellation issues, I’d just have the overhead for insurance. Keep fighting the good fight, you’ll eventually get a setup that works well for you.

  25. Kenny Ku

    now 189K for married file jointly that's 5500 per person? or 11000 total for the couple?

  26. DaFarmzist

    This was very helpful!

  27. Andrew Nitzschke

    Good information as always. I was hoping you would touch on other options for saving for retirement if you get capped for max contributions or income limit exceeded.

U.S. National Debt

The current U.S. national debt:
$34,552,930,923,742

Source

ben stein recessions & depressions

Retirement Age Calculator

  Original Size